Based on the play by Lillian Hellman its remarkable These Three saw the light of day. Hellman’s play, The Children’s Hour, delved into the allure of gossip by telling the story of two women accused of lesbianism. Being 1936, suffice it to say significant changes were made and the result is this first look at the material. Though it isn’t as hard-hitting as Wyler’s remake from 1961 his first pass brims over with pretty people and a premise that remains on the surface of Hellman’s work, if not burrowing under the skin.
Karen Wright (Merle Oberon) and Martha Dobie (Miriam Hopkins) are best friends recently graduated from college. They come upon the idea to open a school for girls which brings them success. Karen soon garners the attention of a local doctor named Joseph (Joel McCrea) whom Martha harbors a quiet crush on. When one of the school’s bad apples (Bonita Granville) accuses Martha and Joseph of carrying on an illicit affair, it threatens the reputation of Karen and Martha, as well as their friendship.
Director William Wyler helmed both this version of Hellman’s material and its later sequel. Both movies have their pros and cons, but the sequel feels like the proper way of presenting the story.
The Children’s Hour always remained a serious drama, but These Three spends its first third playing like Mr. Blandings Builds His Dream House (1948) as Martha and Karen fix up the house that will be their school. The chipper music, the old house in need of renovation, and Joel McCrea’s introduction as the charming Dr. Cardin situate this as a romantic drama, leaning heavy on the former, belying the latter half of the film focusing on Martha and Karen clearing their name.
But with a cast comprised of Oberon, Hopkins and McCrea you can’t expect the film to be as gritty and hard-hitting as it should be. Those each worked with dramatic material, it’s hard wiping the Hollywood sheen of These Three. There’s an artificiality that mutes the material and if you’ve watched The Children’s Hour it’s difficult seeing this as anything more than a neutered take on something that, even in 1961, wasn’t focused on enough.
You can put Merle Oberon and Miriam Hopkins in overalls but they’ll still look like Merle Oberon and Miriam Hopkins. Their Karen and Martha, respectively, lack the hard edge Audrey Hepburn or, more accurately, Shirley MacLaine possessed in the remake, but they refuse to back down against the spurious accusations against them. Removing the lesbian angle from the film turns things into a typical love triangle, with Hopkins set up as the “other woman.”
Wyler and Hellman, respectfully, prevent things from turning Karen and Martha into romantic competitors for Joe’s affections. Karen does suspect Martha’s love for Joe but it is the gossip and stress of the situation driving them apart as opposed to Karen believing the rumors are true. Similar to the remake the film does give the weight of the film to the relationship between Karen and Joe, and it works better in a Hollywood production like this than the remake where heterosexuality ends up winning the day.
Bonita Granville and Marcia Mae Jones play the little girls opening up the Pandora’s box of lies. Jones, best remembered as Clara from The Little Princess (1939), spends a lot of time crying, probably because dealing with Shirley Temple was nothing compared to Bonita Granville. Granville, dyed dark hair and all, is ridiculously melodramatic on a level that Margaret O’Brien couldn’t touch. Granville throws herself around, screams, and schemes on a Snidley Whiplash level. The girl who played Mary in the remake was near sociopathic, but here it’s hard to avoid chuckling at how weasel-like Granville is.
These Three provides 1930s audiences with a good overview of Hellman’s play. The entire affair feels perfectly Hollywood – and the actors know how to give good Hollywood – but once you see the ’60s version this can’t feel anything but tame and pleasant.
Interested in purchasing today’s film? If you use the handy link below a small portion is donated to this site! Thanks!
A freelance film critic whose work fuels the Rotten Tomatoes meter. I've been published on The Hollywood Reporter, Remezcla, and The Daily Beast. I've been featured in the L.A. Times. I currently run two podcasts, Citizen Dame and Ticklish Business.